What's on Peter Piper Pizza Menu?

A Friendly Guide to the Peter Piper Pizza Menu (What to Order + Buffet & Deals)

You’ve probably walked past Peter Piper Pizza a bunch of times — colorful signage, laughter or arcade sounds drifting out the door, and groups of families or friends heading in for dinner.

But if you've ever walked into it, you already know it's not just about grabbing a fancy artisan pie. Yes, it's a casual, family‑friendly pizza spot but it also happens to have arcade fun and buffet options all under one roof.

The menu leans heavily on fresh dough, customizable pizzas, shareable sides, and crowd-friendly combos. Most items are designed for groups, families, and casual hangouts rather than fancy dining. One thing they emphasize is that their dough is made fresh daily, which gives their pizzas that slightly chewy, soft base that fans tend to love.

If you’re wondering what’s actually on the menu and whether the buffet or deals are worth it, here’s a real, easy-to-digest breakdown. Let’s go through it like we’re planning your next visit together.

See also: 13 Food Business Ideas for Students

The Star of the Show: Pizza Options

Let’s be honest, you’re here for the pizza.

Classic Favorites

These are your go-to, no-risk options:

• Pepperoni pizza

• Cheese pizza

• 1-topping customizable pizzas

These are simple, familiar, and perfect if you’re sharing with picky eaters.

Specialty Pizzas

If you want something more loaded, they’ve got a decent variety:

• 5-Meat Supreme (pepperoni, beef, ham, sausage, bacon)

• California Veggie

• Chicago Classic

• Hawaiian-style options

There are also rotating or seasonal flavors like spicy or tropical-inspired pizzas that pop up from time to time.

👉 The nice thing is you’re not stuck with what’s on display. If you don’t see your favorite on the buffet, you can actually ask them to make it fresh.

See also: How to Write Instagram Captions That Actually Stop the Scroll

Appetizers

Before you dive into pizza overload, the bread-based sides deserve a little attention.

• Handmade breadsticks (garlic butter, parmesan, herbs)

• Garlic cheese bread (extra cheesy and richer)

These are the kind of starters you end up refilling without thinking.

Wings

If you’re into wings, they offer:

• Buffalo (mild or hot)

• BBQ

• Lemon pepper

You see they’re not trying to compete with a wing-only restaurant, but they’re solid for a pizza place.

Salads (Yes, they exist… and they’re good)

If you want to balance things out (or just feel slightly less guilty), there are simple salad options:

• Caesar salad

• House salad

Nothing fancy here, but they’re fresh and work well alongside heavier items.

Desserts

This is where Peter Piper Pizza quietly wins people over.

Cinnamon Crunch Dessert

This is their signature sweet:

• Warm pan dough

• Cinnamon + brown sugar topping

• Icing drizzle

It’s basically dessert pizza, and honestly, it’s one of the most talked-about items on their menu.

They’ve also experimented with extras like cake slices and ice cream add-ons in some locations.

See also: Dreamed About Money? Here’s What It Could Mean

The Buffet Experience (This is the real highlight :))

Now let’s talk about the thing that makes Peter Piper Pizza stand out: the lunch buffet.

What’s included?

The weekday buffet typically offers:

• Unlimited pizza (rotating flavors)

• Breadsticks and cheesy sides

• Fresh salad bar

• Dessert (including Cinnamon Crunch)

Everything is refillable, and they’ll even make custom pizzas if you ask.

When is it available?

• Monday to Friday

• Usually from 11 AM to 2 PM

Is it worth it?

Honestly, yes, if:

• You’re hungry

• You like variety

• You’re dining with friends or coworkers

It’s positioned as a value meal, often priced lower than ordering multiple items separately.

See also: 10 Beautiful Flowers That Symbolize New Beginnings

Deals and Combos

Peter Piper Pizza leans heavily into deals, especially for families.

Common Deals You’ll See

• Buy one, get one buffet offers

• Free breadsticks or drinks with combos

• Discounted second pizza

• Coupon books with multiple offers

Family Combos

These usually include:

• Multiple large pizzas

• Drinks

• A starter (like breadsticks)

Perfect if you’re going with a group or hosting a small party.

Pizza + Play Deals

This is where things get interesting:

• Pizza + arcade game credits

So you’re not just eating, you’re basically booking an experience.

See also: 7 Marine Collagen Benefits That Might Surprise You

Drinks and Extras

The beverage options are what you’d expect:

• Fountain drinks

• Bottled water

• Occasionally beer and wine (depending on location)

Nothing groundbreaking, but it gets the job done.

Dine-In, Takeout, or Delivery?

You’ve got options depending on your mood:

• Dine-in (best for buffet and games)

• Takeout

• Delivery

The dine-in experience is really where Peter Piper Pizza shines because of the arcade-style environment and family vibe.

What People Actually Like (Real Talk)

From what regulars say and what the menu suggests:

✔ Great for groups and families
✔ Buffet offers solid value
✔ Dessert pizza is a standout
✔ Custom pizza requests are a plus

Some people don’t go in expecting gourmet pizza, and that’s the right mindset. It’s more about fun, variety, and comfort food than artisan slices.

See also: 4 Tips for Negotiating Salary Over Email[+2 Sample Emails]

Best Things to Order (If you’re going for the first time)

If we were guiding a friend, we’d say:

• Start with the buffet (if available)

• Try at least one specialty pizza

• Don’t skip the breadsticks

• Save room for Cinnamon Crunch

Trust us, this combination pretty much gives you the full experience.

So, is the Peter Piper Pizza menu worth it?

If you’re expecting a high-end pizza restaurant, this isn’t it.

But if you want:

• A relaxed, fun environment

• Lots of food options

• Good value for money

• A place where everyone finds something they like

Then Peter Piper Pizza does exactly what it promises.

See also: Your Business Needs a Virtual Office Manager. Here’s Why.